Exploring multi-dimensional spaces: a Comparison of Latin Hypercube and Quasi Monte Carlo Sampling Techniques
نویسندگان
چکیده
Three sampling methods are compared for efficiency on a number of test problems of various complexity for which analytic quadratures are available. The methods compared are Monte Carlo with pseudo-random numbers, Latin Hypercube Sampling, and Quasi Monte Carlo with sampling based on Sobol’ sequences. Generally results show superior performance of the Quasi Monte Carlo approach based on Sobol’ sequences in line with theoretical predictions. Latin Hypercube Sampling can be more efficient than both Monte Carlo method and Quasi Monte Carlo method but the latter inequality holds for a reduced set of function typology and at small number of sampled points. In conclusion Quasi Monte Carlo method would appear the safest bet when integrating functions of unknown typology.
منابع مشابه
An Empirical Evaluation of Sampling Methods in Risk Analysis Simulation: Quasi-monte Carlo, Descriptive Sampling, and Latin Hypercube Sampling
This paper compares the performance, in terms of convergence rates and precision of the estimates, for six Monte Carlo Simulation sampling methods: Quasi-Monte Carlo using Halton, Sobol, and Faure numeric sequences; Descriptive Sampling, based on the use of deterministic sets and Latin Hypercube Sampling, based on stratified numerical sets. Those methods are compared to the classical Monte Carl...
متن کاملAlternative Sampling Methods for Estimating Multivariate Normal Probabilities
We study the performance of alternative sampling methods for estimating multivariate normal probabilities through the GHK simulator. The sampling methods are randomized versions of some quasi-Monte Carlo samples (Halton, Niederreiter, Niederreiter-Xing sequences and lattice points) and some samples based on orthogonal arrays (Latin hypercube, orthogonal array and orthogonal array based Latin hy...
متن کاملImplementing quasi-Monte Carlo simulations with linear transformations
Pricing exotic multi-asset path-dependent options requires extensive Monte Carlo simulations. In the recent years the interest to the Quasi-monte Carlo technique has been renewed and several results have been proposed in order to improve its efficiency with the notion of effective dimension. To this aim, Imai and Tan introduced a general variance reduction technique in order to minimize the nom...
متن کاملMonte Carlo Extension of Quasi-monte Carlo
This paper surveys recent research on using Monte Carlo techniques to improve quasi-Monte Carlo techniques. Randomized quasi-Monte Carlo methods provide a basis for error estimation. They have, in the special case of scrambled nets, also been observed to improve accuracy. Finally through Latin supercube sampling it is possible to use Monte Carlo methods to extend quasi-Monte Carlo methods to hi...
متن کاملAIAA - 2003 - 2008 Initial Application and Evaluation of a Promising New Sampling Method for Response Surface Generation : Centroidal Voronoi Tessellation
A recently developed Centroidal Voronoi Tessellation (CVT) sampling method is investigated here to assess its suitability for use in response surface generation. CVT is an unstructured sampling method that can generate nearly uniform point spacing over arbitrarily shaped Mdimensional parameter spaces. For rectangular parameter spaces (hypercubes), CVT appears to extend to higher dimensions more...
متن کامل